New year, new you… new mattress?
Make 2024 the year that you finally retire that lumpy old pile of feathers that’s been killing your sleep and torturing your back muscles.
Start your new bed search with the 10 high-quality mattresses highlighted below. This is Home of Cozy’s list of the best mattresses of 2024.
Table of Contents
How to Choose the Best Mattress for Your Needs
Choosing the right mattress involves setting a budget and determining your needs based on your sleep style, body type, and comfort preferences. Here’s a brief review of the main factors to consider while comparing mattress brands and models.
Types of Mattresses
The four most common types of mattresses are:
- Innerspring: a steel coil core covered in a thin layer of padding
- Foam: a high-density foam base and memory foam or polyfoam comfort layers
- Latex: layers of natural or synthetic latex; latex mattresses perform similarly to foam mattresses but with a more rubbery feel
- Hybrid: a coil core topped with thick foam comfort layers
Innerspring mattresses used to be the norm, but they’re a rarity in the modern online mattress world. Most online mattress retailers primarily sell foam or hybrid models. Natural latex or synthetic latex foam are used in some high-end designs.
Budget
The online mattress price range is broad, with luxury designs costing several times more than budget models. The lowest-priced queen-size mattresses cost around $500, with some pricier beds costing over $3k. Queen size prices for the 10 picks featured in this guide are between $599 and $2k.
Sleep Style and Body Type
Your preferred sleeping position and your body type influence which sort of mattress you’ll sleep best on.
Stomach sleepers and back sleepers tend to like firm mattresses. A firmer sleep surface helps with spine and neck alignment in these positions. If your mattress can’t properly support your hips while you’re lying flat on your back or belly, your spine assumes an unnatural curve that often results in lower back pain.
Likewise, sleepers with heavy body weights usually do best on firm beds. Softer mattresses may create an uncomfortable “sinking in” feeling.
Side sleepers typically prefer a slightly softer mattress. A softer sleep surface provides cushioning and pressure relief under the hips and shoulders. Petite sleepers also tend to prefer some softness, since firmer mattresses are designed to resist pressure and thus don’t offer much contouring for light-bodied sleepers.
Firmness Preference
To help online shoppers understand how different mattresses feel, the bedding industry uses an unofficial 1–10 firmness scale.
The firmness scale is arranged as follows:
- 1/10 indicates an extremely soft mattress that allows deep sinking
- 10/10 indicates maximum firmness, permitting no sinking or contouring
- 6.5/10 is the industry standard for a medium-firm mattress
Our Top 10 Picks for the Best Mattresses in 2024
The 10 selections below cover a broad price range and accommodate all types of sleepers. Based on overall quality and value, here are the top mattresses of 2024.
| Brand | Best For | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Editor’s Choice |
| Overall | Shop Now |
| 2 |
| For the Money | Shop Now |
| 3 |
| Hybrid | Shop Now |
| 4 |
| Luxury | Shop Now |
| 5 |
| Memory Foam | Shop Now |
| 6 |
| Organic | Shop Now |
| 7 |
| Soft | Shop Now |
| 8 |
| Firm | Shop Now |
| 9 |
| Plus Size | Shop Now |
| 10 |
| Budget | Shop Now |
| 1 |
|---|
| Editor’s Choice Best For: Overall |
| 2 |
| Best For: For the Money |
| 3 |
| Best For: Hybrid |
| 4 |
| Best For: Luxury |
| 5 |
| Best For: Memory Foam |
| 6 |
| Best For: Organic |
| 7 |
| Best For: Soft |
| 8 |
| Best For: Firm |
| 9 |
| Best For: Plus Size |
| 10 |
| Best For: Budget |
Best Overall: Helix Midnight Luxe
- Best For: Overall
- Price: $1,099–$2,299
- Mattress Type: Hybrid
- Firmness: 5.5/10
- Trial Period: 100 nights
- Warranty: 15 years
What I Loved About This Helix Mattress
Helix and other bed retailers use the “luxe” designation to indicate their higher-end offerings. Often, luxe mattresses are upgraded versions of standard models. That’s the case with the Helix Midnight and the Helix Midnight Luxe (read our Midnight vs. Midnight Luxe comparison guide to learn more).
The original Midnight is Helix’s top seller thanks to a medium-firm feel that really hits the firm-yet-cozy sweet spot. The Midnight Luxe goes the extra mile by adding an extra 2” of height (13.5” total) for extra support plus zoned lumbar support for enhanced contouring and pressure relief.It’s no surprise that the Midnight Luxe has been awarded best mattress for 2024 by GQ, USAToday and other respected publications.
What I Didn’t Love
This mattress feels spectacular. However, among the Midnight Luxe’s thousands of five-star reviews, the most common complaint is that it’s softer than expected. That’s why it’s important to understand the firmness scale and to know your own firmness preference. The Midnight Luxe is rated 5.5/10 firmness. That means it’s medium firm, but closer to soft than to firm.
Best for the Money: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid
- Best For: Bang for your Buck
- Price: $498.80–$1,199
- Mattress Type: Hybrid
- Firmness: available in soft (3/10), medium (5/10), or firm (7/10)
- Trial Period: 120 nights
- Warranty: 10 years
What I Loved About This Brooklyn Bedding Mattress
The Brooklyn Bedding Signature hybrid offers a terrific combo of quality and affordability. It’s an 11” hybrid with an 8” coil core, providing a strong, supportive, and responsive sleep surface. The comfort layers include VariFlex™ transition foam, hyperelastic comfort foam, and a breathable quilted top. The feel is responsive and buoyant, and surprisingly luxurious considering the great price.
Signature Hybrid shoppers can choose between a soft, medium, or firm model, with respective firmness ratings of 3/10, 5/10, and 7/10. The same materials are used for all three options, but in varying proportions in order to create the three different firmness levels.
What I Didn’t Love
The Signature Hybrid’s edge support is just so-so. Heavy-bodied sleepers will feel some slight dipping while lying down on the mattress’s edges and substantial sinking while sitting down on the side of the bed.
Best Hybrid Mattress: Leesa Sapira Hybrid
- Best For: Hybrid Design
- Price: $1,199–$1,899
- Mattress Type: Hybrid
- Firmness: 6.5/10
- Trial Period: 100 nights
- Warranty: 10 years
What I Loved About This Leesa Mattress
The Leesa Sapira Hybrid is an 11” mattress with a 6.5/10 firmness rating that puts it right in the middle of the medium-firm range. Underneath three separate layers of comfort foam, the coil core is made up of over 1,000 active-response pocketed springs.
The use of so many individually wrapped coils helps to create a sleep surface that’s responsive and pressure-relieving. The feel is also slightly buoyant and bouncy. At the same time, the Sapira Hybrid offers impressive motion isolation; you can get in and out of bed without sending any motion transfer ripples that might bother your partner.
If you shop with Leesa, you’ll contribute to their impressive charity program. For every 10 mattresses sold, Leesa donates one mattress to a family in need.
What I Didn’t Love
The highly-responsive and airy feel of the Sapira Hybrid provides excellent pressure relief for side sleepers and light-bodied individuals. However, I wouldn’t recommend this mattress for heavy-bodied sleepers or stomach sleepers who need major support around the hips.
Best Luxury Mattress: Nolah Evolution 15”
- Best For: Luxury design
- Price: $1,199–$2,558
- Mattress Type: Hybrid
- Firmness: available in plush (4.5/10), luxury firm (6.5/10), or firm (7.5/10)
- Trial Period: 120 nights
- Warranty: Lifetime
What I Loved About This Nolah Mattress
Thicker mattresses (12” and up) are associated with durability, luxury, and superior comfort. You’ll find those qualities in our pick for best luxury design, the Nolah Evolution 15”.
The Nolah Evolution’s impressive height consists of seven distinct layers: a plant fiber foundation, an 8” coil core, three layers of foam, a heat escape gusset, and a cooling quilted Euro topper.
This mattress gets high grades in every category, including edge support, motion isolation, and overall comfort. The Nolah Evolution 15” comes in three different firmness options, meaning that anyone who’s interested in this mattress can customize their selection to match their sleep style and preferences.
What I Didn’t Love
The Nolah Evolution 15” is luxurious. It’s also pricey. At nearly $2k for a queen size, this mattress won’t meet the budget requirements for many shoppers.
Best Memory Foam Mattress: Bear Original
- Best For: Memory foam
- Price: $487–$1,055
- Mattress Type: Foam
- Firmness: 7.1/10
- Trial Period: 120 nights
- Warranty: Lifetime
What I Loved About This Bear Mattress
We’ve selected the Bear Original as our pick for the best memory foam mattress, but we could have just as easily named it a top pick for value. This mattress is priced for the bargain bin but performs more like a high-end model.
From bottom to top, the Bear Original’s construction includes a high-density base foam layer, a Bear Dynamic Foam transition layer, a cooling gel memory foam comfort layer, and a breathable quilted cover. The gel foam assists with temperature regulation while establishing a supportive and responsive sleep surface.
The Bear Original is firmer than most memory foam models. The surface is supportive enough for back and stomach sleepers but provides just enough contouring for side sleepers, making this mattress a great choice for couples and combination sleepers.
What I Didn’t Love
The Bear Original is firmer than most foam beds, but it’s also quite lightweight, with a queen size weighing just 70 lbs. As such, I wouldn’t recommend this mattress for sleepers who weigh over 250 lbs. Lightweight foam mattresses don’t hold up well over time when used by heavy-bodied sleepers.
Best Organic Mattress: Birch Natural
- Best For: Organic and Natural Materials
- Price: $999–$1,749
- Mattress Type: Hybrid
- Firmness: 6.5/10
- Trial Period: 100 nights
- Warranty: 25 years
What I Loved About This Birch Mattress
If you’ve opened up a new bed-in-a-box recently, you may be familiar with the phenomenon known as off-gassing, when vacuum-sealed chemical byproducts from the mattress manufacturing process release a foul odor. The smell lingers for a few hours up to a few days. Off-gassing isn’t harmful but it’s a major turnoff for some folks.
With an all-natural product like the Birch Natural, there’s no off-gassing.
From bottom to top, this mattress’s impressive construction includes:
- An organic wool base layer
- 1,000 individually-wrapped coils with reinforced sides
- Natural Talalay latex
- An organic wool top layer
- A breathable organic cotton cover
Birch prioritizes clean materials and sustainability. The Birch Natural’s certifications include GREENGUARD Gold (for chemical emissions control) and the Global Organic Textile Standard (for meeting organic cotton production standards).
The use of natural latex drives up a mattress’s price but helps create a heavenly sleep surface. Latex is responsive and slightly bouncy, offering contouring and pressure relief without compromising firmness and support. The Birch Natural combines latex with coils and wool with fabulous results, creating a medium-firm surface that will feel incredible for the vast majority of sleepers.
What I Didn’t Love
The Birch Natural’s surface is responsive and buoyant. In all sleep positions, the mattress supports your weight and gently cradles your pressure points. The only drawback of the Birch Natural’s unique construction is that motion isolation is somewhat lacking. When one partner moves around on their side of the bed, the other partner will detect slight ripples of motion.
Best Soft Mattress: Helix Sunset
- Best For: Soft Sleep Surface
- Price: $749–$1,399
- Mattress Type: Hybrid
- Firmness: 2.5/10
- Trial Period: 100 nights
- Warranty: 10 years
What I Loved About This Helix Mattress
Helix Sleep’s softest mattress is the Sunset, at 2.5/10 on the firmness scale. Not many hybrid designs offer this much pressure relief and contouring.
Typically, hybrid mattresses feel fairly firm and slightly bouncy. That’s due to the strength and pressure resistance built into the coil core.
The Helix Sunset is a hybrid with a core of over 1,000 individually wrapped coils. This core provides the support we expect from hybrids. However, the top foam layers are extra plush, resulting in the mattress’s higher degree of contouring and cushioning.
I recommend the Helix Sunset to shoppers who are looking for a soft mattress but prefer the durability and support of a hybrid over the squishy softness of an all-foam mattress.
Compared to most online mattress retailers, Helix makes a greater variety of designs that cover a wider range of firmness levels. If you’re interested in buying a Helix but you’re not sure if the Sunset might be too soft, then check out the Helix Sleep Quiz.
What I Didn’t Love
As the softest mattress in our top-10 list, the Helix Sunset is unlikely to be a good match for most back or stomach sleepers or for individuals who weigh over 230 lbs.
Best Firm Mattress: Plank Firm Luxe
- Best For: Extra Firm Sleep Surface
- Price: $693–$1,299
- Mattress Type: hybrid
- Firmness: firm side (7.5/10) and ultra-firm side (9/10)
- Trial Period: 120 nights
- Warranty: 10 years
What I Loved About This Plank Mattress
The Plank Firm Luxe is flippable, offering the choice between a 7.5/10 firm side or a 9/10 ultra-firm side. The firm side will feel “just right” for most back or stomach sleepers. Meanwhile, the ultra-firm side offers one of the firmest sleep surfaces you’ll find, providing a welcome option for sleepers who need extreme support for back pain relief.
This model is actually a plusher upgrade from the original Plank Firm, which features sides of 8/10 and 10/10 firmness. The Plank Firm Luxe offers nearly as much firmness, with just a tad more pressure relief.
Even side sleepers or light-bodied sleepers are likely to be pleasantly surprised by the Plank Firm Luxe. The feel is decidedly firm, permitting zero sinking, but it doesn’t feel hard or stiff. There’s just enough contouring to soften the point of contact without compressing downward.
What I Didn’t Love
Very firm mattresses like the Plank Firm Luxe tend to transfer motion, i.e. radiate movement across the surface of the bed. If a mattress offers minimal compression, then it can’t absorb pressure without distributing some motion from one side of the bed to the other.
The Plank Firm Luxe isolates motion better than the original Plank Firm, but still underperforms in this area compared to softer hybrids. Sensitive sleepers may be bothered by the movements of their partner getting in and out of bed.
Best for Plus-Size: Titan Plus Luxe
- Best For: Plus-size Sleepers
- Price: $674.30–$1,349
- Mattress Type: Hybrid
- Firmness: 6/10
- Trial Period: 120 nights
- Warranty: 10 years
What I Loved About This Titan Mattress
The Titan Plux Luxe is designed for heavyweight sleepers. The mattress is 13” tall with a core layer made up of 1,032 individually-encased 13.5 gauge TitanCaliber™ coils. The weight limit is 1,000 lbs.
The Titan Plus Luxe is super strong, but it’s not intensely firm. Most mattresses that are geared toward plus-size sleepers are extra stiff, but here we find more of a mix of comfort and support. That makes the Titan Plus Luxe an ideal choice for heavy-bodied individuals who like to sleep on their sides or who need pressure relief for easing joint pain.
What I Didn’t Love
Many plus-size sleepers prefer extreme firmness. The Titan Plus Luxe provides more of a medium-firm feel. Thus, this mattress is ideal for plus-size side sleepers, but heavy-bodied back and stomach sleepers will likely be better suited for the original Titan Plus (the non-luxe version).
Best Budget: Dreamfoam Hybrid
- Best For: Budget
- Price: $399–$749.25
- Mattress Type: Hybrid
- Firmness: 5/10
- Trial Period: 120 nights
- Warranty: 10 years
What I Loved About This Dreamfoam Mattress
The Brooklyn Bedding Dreamfoam Hybrid is the lowest-priced mattress in our top 10 list and it’s also our pick for 2024’s best value.
The Dreamfoam Hybrid’s construction includes a 1” high-density foam base, a 6” coil core, a 2.5” gel memory foam comfort layer, and a quilted plush top. Each layer contains temperature regulation features that make this model a great choice for hot sleepers. The individually wrapped coils in the core permit plenty of airflow, while gel cooling beads in the foam layer and phase change material (PCM) in the quilted top help to prevent overheating.
Along with its cooling features, the Dreamfoam Hybrid offers a medium-firm feel, leaning more towards the softer end of the medium-firm range. Side sleepers will enjoy plenty of pressure relief and couples will appreciate the mattress’s impressive ability to isolate motion for a comfy shared night’s sleep.
What I Didn’t Love
I wouldn’t recommend the Dreamfoam Hybrid for heavy-bodied sleepers. The dimensions—10.25 inches tall and just 105 lbs for a king size—are fine for lightweight or medium-sized folks. Plus-size sleepers are better off with a thicker, more substantial construction that provides extra support and durability.
Find the Perfect Mattress for Your Budget
At Home of Cozy, we obsess over mattresses and furniture so that you don’t have to. For more reviews of the top offerings from the best bed-in-a-box brands like Purple, Dreamcloud, Casper, Nectar, Winkbed, and Avocado, check out more Home of Cozy mattress review content, like the Best Mattresses Under $1,000 in 2024, the Best Mattress Toppers for Side Sleepers, or the 12 Best California King Size Mattresses.
